TCM 2, just cuz it was such a long wait and the old one was bare bones. Haven't picked up the original yet, but I'm sure that disc is up there from all I've read and the screen shots I've seen. I'll give honorable mentions to Feast and Slither. Both great comedy/horror fun and nicely loaded discs.
vote for Hostel here. Roth is a douche, but I dig the film. also, loved the Masters of Horror treatments, and kudos to the Gruesome Edition of The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2
Pfft?!?! Whats up? Theres no love for the Hills have Eyes? I mean come on people, Hills is one of the best remakes i've ever seen, its way better then any of the TCM remakes.
For me, the most affecting film in there with Spirit of the Beehive. I'm glad I got to see this on DVD, so it got my vote.
I'm surprised the infinifilm edition of A Nightmare on Elm Street didn't make the poll. Aside from the missing original mono track, the film looks better than ever and has a plethora of special features.